{"snapshotDate":"2026-11-03","researchUpdatedAt":"2026-11-07T19:57:03.719Z","qualification":"Dated source claims and observations; no independent assessment, legal-entity verification or current availability guarantee","fieldGuide":"The listing contains the resolved profile values. The record preserves the underlying observations. Snapshot and research update dates at the top apply to the datasets. Each public test has its own date, scope and sources.","listing":{"name":"Convexly","category":"Analytics and wallet tracking","canonicalId":"VE-284242f01603a5aa","url":"https://vultax.com/business-directory/convexly","venues":["Polymarket"],"pricingGroup":"mixed","pricing":"Free: $0/month. Public wallet check; 1 watched wallet; Monday digest Watchlist: $9/month. 3 watched wallets; 3 full-history reads every 30 days; CSV; Other billing options: $90/year Researcher: $49/month. 10 watched wallets; 10 full-history reads every 30 days; resolution research and API; Other billing options: $490/year Trader: $499/month. 25 watched wallets; 50 full-history reads every 7 days; five-minute activity polling; Other billing options: $4990/year One-time read: $19/one purchase. One dated on-chain reconciled wallet read; no ongoing monitoring Enterprise: Custom. Scoped pilot or cohort from 100 wallets; by agreement","researchCheckedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","latestPublicCheckOn":null,"currentCheckedTier":null,"checkResultsUrl":"https://vultax.com/business-directory/convexly/checks.json"},"record":{"id":"VE-284242f01603a5aa","name":"Convexly","website":"https://www.convexly.app/","sourceUrl":"https://www.convexly.app/","observedAt":"2026-10-30T14:09:50.161304+00:00","sourceHash":"6768b41f584b54787a2966233eef785443ec536ad8c38c8c32dea92ecfad8c00","reviewStatus":"not_assessed","firstPartyObserved":true,"metadata":[{"id":"VF-b3b0aed2a52f36a88e30","field":"page_declared_profile_urls","value":["https://x.com/convexlyapp"],"sourceUrl":"https://www.convexly.app/","observedAt":"2026-10-30T14:09:50.161304+00:00","scope":"Cited page metadata; embedded entity/product matching is not independently certified","qualification":"An offer is not proof of sales, free service, current availability or a customer contract. A page-declared operator/date is a source claim, not registry verification."},{"id":"VF-1bc4d6fcc295a9d684c0","field":"page_declared_profile_urls","value":["https://x.com/convexlyapp"],"sourceUrl":"https://www.convexly.app/pricing","observedAt":"2026-10-30T14:09:51.704445+00:00","scope":"Cited page metadata; embedded entity/product matching is not independently certified","qualification":"An offer is not proof of sales, free service, current availability or a customer contract. A page-declared operator/date is a source claim, not registry verification."},{"id":"VF-dfcaaa92e26495e00031","field":"page_declared_profile_urls","value":["https://x.com/convexlyapp"],"sourceUrl":"https://www.convexly.app/privacy","observedAt":"2026-10-30T14:09:52.398052+00:00","scope":"Cited page metadata; embedded entity/product matching is not independently certified","qualification":"An offer is not proof of sales, free service, current availability or a customer contract. A page-declared operator/date is a source claim, not registry verification."},{"id":"VF-ac6d81c7134935c4a3da","field":"page_declared_profile_urls","value":["https://x.com/convexlyapp"],"sourceUrl":"https://www.convexly.app/terms","observedAt":"2026-10-30T14:09:53.075401+00:00","scope":"Cited page metadata; embedded entity/product matching is not independently certified","qualification":"An offer is not proof of sales, free service, current availability or a customer contract. A page-declared operator/date is a source claim, not registry verification."},{"id":"VF-010461455c943a01df18","field":"page_declared_profile_urls","value":["https://x.com/convexlyapp"],"sourceUrl":"https://www.convexly.app/api-docs","observedAt":"2026-10-30T14:09:53.576026+00:00","scope":"Cited page metadata; embedded entity/product matching is not independently certified","qualification":"An offer is not proof of sales, free service, current availability or a customer contract. A page-declared operator/date is a source claim, not registry verification."},{"id":"VF-5ff6617e7e1c007d3713","field":"page_declared_profile_urls","value":["https://x.com/convexlyapp"],"sourceUrl":"https://www.convexly.app/blog","observedAt":"2026-10-30T14:09:55.539132+00:00","scope":"Cited page metadata; embedded entity/product matching is not independently certified","qualification":"An offer is not proof of sales, free service, current availability or a customer contract. A page-declared operator/date is a source claim, not registry verification."},{"id":"VF-481b706a61d96a00b2ac","field":"page_declared_profile_urls","value":["https://x.com/convexlyapp"],"sourceUrl":"https://www.convexly.app/about","observedAt":"2026-10-30T14:09:56.197220+00:00","scope":"Cited page metadata; embedded entity/product matching is not independently certified","qualification":"An offer is not proof of sales, free service, current availability or a customer contract. A page-declared operator/date is a source claim, not registry verification."}],"observations":[{"id":"VW-3e6b4fe76f523cf0","sourceUrl":"https://www.convexly.app/","observedAt":"2026-10-30T14:09:50.161304+00:00","sourceHash":"6768b41f584b54787a2966233eef785443ec536ad8c38c8c32dea92ecfad8c00","qualification":"This is our dated page observation, not a verified company identity, prediction-market classification, current service-health claim or API benchmark."}],"catalogueHistory":[],"repositoryLinks":[],"category":null,"venues":[],"pricingGroup":"unclear","reportedOpenSource":null,"reportedExecution":null,"research":{"id":"VE-284242f01603a5aa","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","resourceType":"Product or service","availability":{"state":"page_observed","detail":"A public first-party product or documentation page was obtained; account access and service operation were not tested."},"sources":[{"id":"7145e25e4c14f028","url":"https://www.convexly.app/","observedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:14.645372+00:00","bodySha256":"9df7eb5ec464321caebc4387cc43def0c305e6fe474185cc7fe5fb28a53b0adf","kind":"Homepage"},{"id":"9721ba6005b99648","url":"https://www.convexly.app/pricing","observedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:15.507788+00:00","bodySha256":"6d57b452bdcd23497b83684b5a75db7c35ab985ba9f4c695ad3d3f1a9bf87861","kind":"Pricing"},{"id":"85d829fc4a775a77","url":"https://www.convexly.app/about","observedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:17.498286+00:00","bodySha256":"230bd2ff24116075ffa30356a0577fae13c926d7ed80858d6b5c070df11b124a","kind":"About"},{"id":"e3b6143a2b61a42b","url":"https://www.convexly.app/api-docs","observedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:16.879357+00:00","bodySha256":"6a86ed6340a65a5073bed043caa995cba024cbe3e02e3c845444da127c046541","kind":"Documentation"},{"id":"3c2d325f093956b4","url":"https://www.convexly.app/terms","observedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:16.141430+00:00","bodySha256":"915d7cd48aa564a7d257b7da16dc0a36b217fd82c29d3f1b0d4b0a43a8f909f9","kind":"Terms"},{"id":"b665bd072c8a43d9","url":"https://www.convexly.app/markets/resolution-lab","observedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:05.436Z","bodySha256":"f747f19587101a09bdbe453460d98977e50f54c3620f56a0704a3bae616eff5d","kind":"Pricing"},{"id":"9661abd639f5ed7c","url":"https://www.convexly.app/pricing","observedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","bodySha256":"41b9dda7f649f5e42360fcb485fbc8208ac9a59db7c20325a4ca049a27935101","kind":"Pricing"}],"platforms":[{"text":"Polymarket","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028"]}],"features":[{"label":"Wallet research","detail":"Wallet activity, trader tracking or wallet scoring is described.","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028"]}],"plans":[{"name":"Free","price":"$0/month","terms":"Public wallet check; 1 watched wallet; Monday digest","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"]},{"name":"Watchlist","price":"$9/month","terms":"3 watched wallets; 3 full-history reads every 30 days; CSV; Other billing options: $90/year","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"]},{"name":"Researcher","price":"$49/month","terms":"10 watched wallets; 10 full-history reads every 30 days; resolution research and API; Other billing options: $490/year","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"]},{"name":"Trader","price":"$499/month","terms":"25 watched wallets; 50 full-history reads every 7 days; five-minute activity polling; Other billing options: $4990/year","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"]},{"name":"One-time read","price":"$19/one purchase","terms":"One dated on-chain reconciled wallet read; no ongoing monitoring","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"]},{"name":"Enterprise","price":"Custom","terms":"Scoped pilot or cohort from 100 wallets; by agreement","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"]}],"facts":[{"label":"Operator named in terms","text":"Convexly LLC; described as a Wyoming limited liability company. This is the provider’s statement; no business-registry verification is implied.","sourceIds":["3c2d325f093956b4"]}],"links":[{"kind":"pricing","label":"Pricing","url":"https://www.convexly.app/pricing","sourceIds":["9721ba6005b99648"]},{"kind":"about","label":"About the product","url":"https://www.convexly.app/about","sourceIds":["85d829fc4a775a77"]},{"kind":"documentation","label":"Documentation","url":"https://www.convexly.app/api-docs","sourceIds":["e3b6143a2b61a42b"]}],"summary":{"text":"Convexly checks public Polymarket wallet records and monitors selected wallets for changes. Paid plans increase watched-wallet and reconciled-history allowances, with separate one-time reads and institutional engagements. The pricing page explicitly warns that activity notices can miss trades and are not a complete history.","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"]},"category":{"text":"Analytics & dashboards","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028"]},"excerpt":{"text":"Check a Polymarket wallet’s reported P&L, resolved positions and data coverage. First check free, no signup. No venue buys coverage.","sourceId":"7145e25e4c14f028"},"pricing":{"text":"Free: $0/month. Public wallet check; 1 watched wallet; Monday digest Watchlist: $9/month. 3 watched wallets; 3 full-history reads every 30 days; CSV; Other billing options: $90/year Researcher: $49/month. 10 watched wallets; 10 full-history reads every 30 days; resolution research and API; Other billing options: $490/year Trader: $499/month. 25 watched wallets; 50 full-history reads every 7 days; five-minute activity polling; Other billing options: $4990/year One-time read: $19/one purchase. One dated on-chain reconciled wallet read; no ongoing monitoring Enterprise: Custom. Scoped pilot or cohort from 100 wallets; by agreement","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"]},"pricingGroup":"mixed","schemaVersion":2,"fields":{"f01":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":"Polymarket wallet checks, scheduled record reviews and evidence exports"},"f02":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":"Convexly checks public Polymarket wallet records and monitors selected wallets for changes. Paid plans increase watched-wallet and reconciled-history allowances, with separate one-time reads and institutional engagements. The pricing page explicitly warns that activity notices can miss trades and are not a complete history."},"f03":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f04":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f05":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f06":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":["Web"]},"f07":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f08":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":[{"kind":"pricing","url":"https://www.convexly.app/pricing"}]},"f09":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f10":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f11":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f12":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f13":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:14.645372+00:00","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028"],"reason":"Migrated source-backed legacy field; not re-reviewed by this parity pass.","value":[{"label":"Wallet research","detail":"Wallet activity, trader tracking or wallet scoring is described.","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028"]}],"coverage":"partial","unresolvedParts":["Full parity review pending"]},"f14":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f15":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f16":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f17":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f18":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f19":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":["Web","Email","CSV","API"]},"f20":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f21":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":[{"name":"Free","prices":[{"amount":0,"currency":"USD","period":"free"}],"includes":["Public wallet check; 1 watched wallet; Monday digest"]},{"name":"Watchlist","prices":[{"amount":9,"currency":"USD","period":"month"},{"amount":90,"currency":"USD","period":"year"}],"includes":["3 watched wallets; 3 full-history reads every 30 days; CSV"]},{"name":"Researcher","prices":[{"amount":49,"currency":"USD","period":"month"},{"amount":490,"currency":"USD","period":"year"}],"includes":["10 watched wallets; 10 full-history reads every 30 days; resolution research and API"]},{"name":"Trader","prices":[{"amount":499,"currency":"USD","period":"month"},{"amount":4990,"currency":"USD","period":"year"}],"includes":["25 watched wallets; 50 full-history reads every 7 days; five-minute activity polling"]},{"name":"One-time read","prices":[{"amount":19,"currency":"USD","period":"one purchase"}],"includes":["One dated on-chain reconciled wallet read; no ongoing monitoring"]},{"name":"Enterprise","prices":[{"amount":"Custom","currency":"USD","period":"Engagement"}],"includes":["Scoped pilot or cohort from 100 wallets; by agreement"]}]},"f22":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":{"watchedWallets":1,"initialCheck":"No signup or wallet connection required","activityNoticeMaximum":"Once per wallet per 20 hours; activity in between is not accumulated"}},"f23":{"state":"not_stated","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Not stated in the specifically reviewed public pages; this is a bounded observation, not a claim about inaccessible documentation or checkout.","coverage":"partial"},"f24":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f25":{"state":"not_stated","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Not stated in the specifically reviewed public pages; this is a bounded observation, not a claim about inaccessible documentation or checkout.","coverage":"partial"},"f26":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":{"subscription":"USD 9/49/499 monthly or USD 90/490/4,990 yearly; one-time read USD 19; enterprise by agreement"}},"f27":{"state":"not_stated","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Not stated in the specifically reviewed public pages; this is a bounded observation, not a claim about inaccessible documentation or checkout.","coverage":"partial"},"f28":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f29":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f30":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f31":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f32":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f33":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Dated page observations retained as a series; these are bounded checks, not uptime measurements.","coverage":"complete","value":[{"eventId":"eae041238f7c6063b7ee24d8","checkedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:17.498286+00:00","state":"page_observed","detail":"Public page content was obtained during the dated check. Reachability does not establish continuing service availability.","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028","9721ba6005b99648","85d829fc4a775a77","e3b6143a2b61a42b","3c2d325f093956b4"],"basis":"imported_dated_profile_check"},{"eventId":"8bf2a9c8f247c1fe94103bdb","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:05.436Z","state":"page_observed","detail":"A public first-party product or documentation page was obtained; account access and service operation were not tested.","sourceIds":["b665bd072c8a43d9"],"basis":"bounded_public_source_probe"},{"eventId":"697e30d7b3444d1908444c69","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","state":"page_observed","detail":"A public first-party product or documentation page was obtained; account access and service operation were not tested.","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"basis":"bounded_public_source_probe"}]},"f34":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f35":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f36":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f37":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f38":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f39":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f40":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f41":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f42":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","unresolvedParts":["Terms text, KYC and geographic eligibility not reviewed"],"value":{"links":[{"url":"https://www.convexly.app/privacy","label":"Privacy"},{"url":"https://www.convexly.app/terms","label":"Terms"}],"eligibility":"KYC and geographic conditions were not reviewed in this pricing-focused observation."}},"f43":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f44":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f45":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f46":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f47":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f48":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f49":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"operatingStatus":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"statusNotice":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"supportedVenues":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"withdrawals":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"accessConditions":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"openSource":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."}},"history":{"fields":[{"eventId":"63bfe0fed2ee852a36710667","fieldId":"f02","state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:14.645372+00:00","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028"],"reason":"Migrated source-backed legacy field; not re-reviewed by this parity pass.","value":"Convexly provides market research and analysis tools. Its overview names Polymarket. Publicly described capabilities include wallet research.","coverage":"partial","unresolvedParts":["Full parity review pending"]},{"eventId":"d91f46110e29ce53411c878b","fieldId":"f13","state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:14.645372+00:00","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028"],"reason":"Migrated source-backed legacy field; not re-reviewed by this parity pass.","value":[{"label":"Wallet research","detail":"Wallet activity, trader tracking or wallet scoring is described.","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028"]}],"coverage":"partial","unresolvedParts":["Full parity review pending"]},{"eventId":"e542328a538743c3dd68269b","fieldId":"f08","state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:17.498286+00:00","sourceIds":["9721ba6005b99648","85d829fc4a775a77","e3b6143a2b61a42b"],"reason":"Migrated source-backed legacy field; not re-reviewed by this parity pass.","value":[{"kind":"pricing","label":"Pricing","url":"https://www.convexly.app/pricing","sourceIds":["9721ba6005b99648"]},{"kind":"about","label":"About the product","url":"https://www.convexly.app/about","sourceIds":["85d829fc4a775a77"]},{"kind":"documentation","label":"Documentation","url":"https://www.convexly.app/api-docs","sourceIds":["e3b6143a2b61a42b"]}],"coverage":"partial","unresolvedParts":["Full parity review pending"]},{"eventId":"eb10f8b1f7c85ac41c7cdc0a","fieldId":"f33","state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:05.436Z","sourceIds":["b665bd072c8a43d9"],"reason":"Dated page observations retained as a series; these are bounded checks, not uptime measurements.","coverage":"complete","value":[{"eventId":"eae041238f7c6063b7ee24d8","checkedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:17.498286+00:00","state":"page_observed","detail":"Public page content was obtained during the dated check. Reachability does not establish continuing service availability.","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028","9721ba6005b99648","85d829fc4a775a77","e3b6143a2b61a42b","3c2d325f093956b4"],"basis":"imported_dated_profile_check"},{"eventId":"8bf2a9c8f247c1fe94103bdb","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:05.436Z","state":"page_observed","detail":"A public first-party product or documentation page was obtained; account access and service operation were not tested.","sourceIds":["b665bd072c8a43d9"],"basis":"bounded_public_source_probe"}]},{"eventId":"cf95b80027a7a027fb19eac0","fieldId":"f21","state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":[{"name":"Free","prices":[{"amount":0,"currency":"USD","period":"free"}],"includes":["Public wallet check; 1 watched wallet; Monday digest"]},{"name":"Watchlist","prices":[{"amount":9,"currency":"USD","period":"month"},{"amount":90,"currency":"USD","period":"year"}],"includes":["3 watched wallets; 3 full-history reads every 30 days; CSV"]},{"name":"Researcher","prices":[{"amount":49,"currency":"USD","period":"month"},{"amount":490,"currency":"USD","period":"year"}],"includes":["10 watched wallets; 10 full-history reads every 30 days; resolution research and API"]},{"name":"Trader","prices":[{"amount":499,"currency":"USD","period":"month"},{"amount":4990,"currency":"USD","period":"year"}],"includes":["25 watched wallets; 50 full-history reads every 7 days; five-minute activity polling"]},{"name":"One-time read","prices":[{"amount":19,"currency":"USD","period":"one purchase"}],"includes":["One dated on-chain reconciled wallet read; no ongoing monitoring"]},{"name":"Enterprise","prices":[{"amount":"Custom","currency":"USD","period":"Engagement"}],"includes":["Scoped pilot or cohort from 100 wallets; by agreement"]}]},{"eventId":"e4fdfad81aaab6ae5a152ba5","fieldId":"f22","state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":{"watchedWallets":1,"initialCheck":"No signup or wallet connection required","activityNoticeMaximum":"Once per wallet per 20 hours; activity in between is not accumulated"}},{"eventId":"4e632657a955fdd512e522f8","fieldId":"f23","state":"not_stated","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Not stated in the specifically reviewed public pages; this is a bounded observation, not a claim about inaccessible documentation or checkout.","coverage":"partial"},{"eventId":"9464fbe8b33ac487f2950124","fieldId":"f25","state":"not_stated","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Not stated in the specifically reviewed public pages; this is a bounded observation, not a claim about inaccessible documentation or checkout.","coverage":"partial"},{"eventId":"e058ec07c4a3a7f0fd279f2a","fieldId":"f26","state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":{"subscription":"USD 9/49/499 monthly or USD 90/490/4,990 yearly; one-time read USD 19; enterprise by agreement"}},{"eventId":"7df3722448dbe0e42b84a1f6","fieldId":"f27","state":"not_stated","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Not stated in the specifically reviewed public pages; this is a bounded observation, not a claim about inaccessible documentation or checkout.","coverage":"partial"},{"eventId":"b22e508a0d5b82fdf53b22ca","fieldId":"f01","state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":"Polymarket wallet checks, scheduled record reviews and evidence exports"},{"eventId":"77b49915b14d7b2b6c86c28d","fieldId":"f02","state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":"Convexly checks public Polymarket wallet records and monitors selected wallets for changes. Paid plans increase watched-wallet and reconciled-history allowances, with separate one-time reads and institutional engagements. The pricing page explicitly warns that activity notices can miss trades and are not a complete history."},{"eventId":"887eafc3bf668314301eb0a1","fieldId":"f06","state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":["Web"]},{"eventId":"a66dd69d02705c90d15b2ab4","fieldId":"f19","state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":["Web","Email","CSV","API"]},{"eventId":"4da71d344e4655e4c4b7df29","fieldId":"f08","state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":[{"kind":"pricing","url":"https://www.convexly.app/pricing"}]},{"eventId":"b05fa04e1fd4d59cc6c483fe","fieldId":"f42","state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","unresolvedParts":["Terms text, KYC and geographic eligibility not reviewed"],"value":{"links":[{"url":"https://www.convexly.app/privacy","label":"Privacy"},{"url":"https://www.convexly.app/terms","label":"Terms"}],"eligibility":"KYC and geographic conditions were not reviewed in this pricing-focused observation."}},{"eventId":"5a2ea572ca7404785ef2ea44","fieldId":"f33","state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Dated page observations retained as a series; these are bounded checks, not uptime measurements.","coverage":"complete","value":[{"eventId":"eae041238f7c6063b7ee24d8","checkedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:17.498286+00:00","state":"page_observed","detail":"Public page content was obtained during the dated check. Reachability does not establish continuing service availability.","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028","9721ba6005b99648","85d829fc4a775a77","e3b6143a2b61a42b","3c2d325f093956b4"],"basis":"imported_dated_profile_check"},{"eventId":"8bf2a9c8f247c1fe94103bdb","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:05.436Z","state":"page_observed","detail":"A public first-party product or documentation page was obtained; account access and service operation were not tested.","sourceIds":["b665bd072c8a43d9"],"basis":"bounded_public_source_probe"},{"eventId":"697e30d7b3444d1908444c69","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","state":"page_observed","detail":"A public first-party product or documentation page was obtained; account access and service operation were not tested.","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"basis":"bounded_public_source_probe"}]}],"availability":[{"eventId":"eae041238f7c6063b7ee24d8","checkedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:17.498286+00:00","state":"page_observed","detail":"Public page content was obtained during the dated check. Reachability does not establish continuing service availability.","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028","9721ba6005b99648","85d829fc4a775a77","e3b6143a2b61a42b","3c2d325f093956b4"],"basis":"imported_dated_profile_check"},{"eventId":"8bf2a9c8f247c1fe94103bdb","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:05.436Z","state":"page_observed","detail":"A public first-party product or documentation page was obtained; account access and service operation were not tested.","sourceIds":["b665bd072c8a43d9"],"basis":"bounded_public_source_probe"},{"eventId":"697e30d7b3444d1908444c69","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","state":"page_observed","detail":"A public first-party product or documentation page was obtained; account access and service operation were not tested.","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"basis":"bounded_public_source_probe"}],"status":[],"pricing":[{"eventId":"06531faf958d7302102ad7fe","checkedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:15.507788+00:00","sourceIds":["9721ba6005b99648"],"snapshot":{"pricing":{"text":"Wallet checks are free. Researcher is advertised at $49/month for rechecking ten monitored wallets and sending change notifications; institutional pilots require a separate discussion.","sourceIds":["9721ba6005b99648"]},"plans":[]},"basis":"imported_dated_price_evidence"},{"eventId":"e4bcf052aaac1e2bf2d99a8d","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"snapshot":{"f21":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":[{"name":"Free","prices":[{"amount":0,"currency":"USD","period":"free"}],"includes":["Public wallet check; 1 watched wallet; Monday digest"]},{"name":"Watchlist","prices":[{"amount":9,"currency":"USD","period":"month"},{"amount":90,"currency":"USD","period":"year"}],"includes":["3 watched wallets; 3 full-history reads every 30 days; CSV"]},{"name":"Researcher","prices":[{"amount":49,"currency":"USD","period":"month"},{"amount":490,"currency":"USD","period":"year"}],"includes":["10 watched wallets; 10 full-history reads every 30 days; resolution research and API"]},{"name":"Trader","prices":[{"amount":499,"currency":"USD","period":"month"},{"amount":4990,"currency":"USD","period":"year"}],"includes":["25 watched wallets; 50 full-history reads every 7 days; five-minute activity polling"]},{"name":"One-time read","prices":[{"amount":19,"currency":"USD","period":"one purchase"}],"includes":["One dated on-chain reconciled wallet read; no ongoing monitoring"]},{"name":"Enterprise","prices":[{"amount":"Custom","currency":"USD","period":"Engagement"}],"includes":["Scoped pilot or cohort from 100 wallets; by agreement"]}]},"f22":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":{"watchedWallets":1,"initialCheck":"No signup or wallet connection required","activityNoticeMaximum":"Once per wallet per 20 hours; activity in between is not accumulated"}},"f23":{"state":"not_stated","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Not stated in the specifically reviewed public pages; this is a bounded observation, not a claim about inaccessible documentation or checkout.","coverage":"partial"},"f25":{"state":"not_stated","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Not stated in the specifically reviewed public pages; this is a bounded observation, not a claim about inaccessible documentation or checkout.","coverage":"partial"},"f26":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Provider-stated facts paraphrased from the specifically reviewed pages; functionality, performance and security were not tested.","coverage":"partial","value":{"subscription":"USD 9/49/499 monthly or USD 90/490/4,990 yearly; one-time read USD 19; enterprise by agreement"}},"f27":{"state":"not_stated","checkedAt":"2026-11-06T13:05:03.434Z","sourceIds":["9661abd639f5ed7c"],"reason":"Not stated in the specifically reviewed public pages; this is a bounded observation, not a claim about inaccessible documentation or checkout.","coverage":"partial"}},"basis":"reviewed_first_party_pricing_2026_11_06"}],"revisions":[{"eventId":"b3738c0e2fcfb31358c2c87b","recordedAt":"2026-11-06T13:17:58.668Z","reason":"6 November batch 2: preserve superseded projection and checked field states before first-party enrichment.","projection":{"id":"VE-284242f01603a5aa","checkedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:17.498286+00:00","resourceType":"Product or service","availability":{"state":"page_observed","detail":"Public page content was obtained during the dated check. Reachability does not establish continuing service availability."},"platforms":[{"text":"Polymarket","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028"]}],"features":[{"label":"Wallet research","detail":"Wallet activity, trader tracking or wallet scoring is described.","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028"]}],"plans":[],"facts":[{"label":"Operator named in terms","text":"Convexly LLC; described as a Wyoming limited liability company. This is the provider’s statement; no business-registry verification is implied.","sourceIds":["3c2d325f093956b4"]}],"links":[{"kind":"pricing","label":"Pricing","url":"https://www.convexly.app/pricing","sourceIds":["9721ba6005b99648"]},{"kind":"about","label":"About the product","url":"https://www.convexly.app/about","sourceIds":["85d829fc4a775a77"]},{"kind":"documentation","label":"Documentation","url":"https://www.convexly.app/api-docs","sourceIds":["e3b6143a2b61a42b"]}],"summary":{"text":"Convexly provides market research and analysis tools. Its overview names Polymarket. Publicly described capabilities include wallet research.","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028"]},"category":{"text":"Analytics & dashboards","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028"]},"excerpt":{"text":"Check a Polymarket wallet’s reported P&L, resolved positions and data coverage. First check free, no signup. No venue buys coverage.","sourceId":"7145e25e4c14f028"},"pricing":{"text":"Wallet checks are free. Researcher is advertised at $49/month for rechecking ten monitored wallets and sending change notifications; institutional pilots require a separate discussion.","sourceIds":["9721ba6005b99648"]},"pricingGroup":"mixed","schemaVersion":2,"fields":{"f01":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f02":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:14.645372+00:00","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028"],"reason":"Migrated source-backed legacy field; not re-reviewed by this parity pass.","value":"Convexly provides market research and analysis tools. Its overview names Polymarket. Publicly described capabilities include wallet research.","coverage":"partial","unresolvedParts":["Full parity review pending"]},"f03":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f04":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f05":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f06":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f07":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f08":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:17.498286+00:00","sourceIds":["9721ba6005b99648","85d829fc4a775a77","e3b6143a2b61a42b"],"reason":"Migrated source-backed legacy field; not re-reviewed by this parity pass.","value":[{"kind":"pricing","label":"Pricing","url":"https://www.convexly.app/pricing","sourceIds":["9721ba6005b99648"]},{"kind":"about","label":"About the product","url":"https://www.convexly.app/about","sourceIds":["85d829fc4a775a77"]},{"kind":"documentation","label":"Documentation","url":"https://www.convexly.app/api-docs","sourceIds":["e3b6143a2b61a42b"]}],"coverage":"partial","unresolvedParts":["Full parity review pending"]},"f09":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f10":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f11":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f12":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f13":{"state":"value","checkedAt":"2026-10-31T02:05:14.645372+00:00","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028"],"reason":"Migrated source-backed legacy field; not re-reviewed by this parity pass.","value":[{"label":"Wallet research","detail":"Wallet activity, trader tracking or wallet scoring is described.","sourceIds":["7145e25e4c14f028"]}],"coverage":"partial","unresolvedParts":["Full parity review pending"]},"f14":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f15":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f16":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f17":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f18":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f19":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f20":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f21":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f22":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f23":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f24":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f25":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f26":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f27":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f28":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f29":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f30":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f31":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f32":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f33":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f34":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f35":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f36":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f37":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f38":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f39":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f40":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f41":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f42":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f43":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f44":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f45":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f46":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f47":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f48":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"f49":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"operatingStatus":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"statusNotice":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"supportedVenues":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"withdrawals":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"accessConditions":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."},"openSource":{"state":"not_checked","checkedAt":null,"sourceIds":[],"reason":"This field has not been reviewed in the parity pass."}}}}]}}},"checkRuns":[],"catalogueChanges":[],"attribution":{"coveredMaterial":"Historical Kairos descriptions and catalogue claims","author":"Kairos contributors","licence":"CC BY 4.0","licenceUrl":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","notice":"https://vultax.com/datasets/prediction-market-directory/KAIROS-ATTRIBUTION.txt","modifications":"Source association, presentation and original factual comparisons by Vultax"}}